Thursday, February 24, 2011

Conference Proposal Final Draft

Expanding Student Awareness of Audience: An Exploration of the Uses of the “Rhetorical Triangle” in Multimodal Video Assignments

In their chapter of Multimodal Composition (ed. Cynthia Selfe) entitled “Responding and Assessing,” Sonya C. Borton and Brian Huot discuss the importance of the student’s awareness of their audience in the creation of multimodal assignments. Borton and Huot state that utilizing the concept of “audience” is an essential component and the driving force for instructor assessment and evaluation of multimodal assignments. Accompanying this, in “Among the Audience: On Audience in an Age of New Literacies,” Andrea A. Lunsford and Lisa Ede expand upon the creator’s perception of their audience, readers, discourse community, or “public.” By empowering students as the authors within their own discourse community, students are able to become active players in their “writer” role within the “Rhetorical Triangle.”

My presentation examines potential avenues for expanding student perception of audience from beyond the concept of the singular multimodal evaluator as the lone “reader” within the “Rhetorical Triangle.” By focusing on C. Selfe’s “Sample Assignment 2” entitled “Video Biography: Literacy Values and Practices,” I will explore the approaches in video biography assignment creation that promote the “writer’s” awareness of a larger discourse community of “readers.” These approaches will include, but are not limited to, discussions of video assignment creation that entail community interaction, the concept of publicly accessible media, and cooperation of willing “readers” within the university setting.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Multimodal Final Project Proposal

Grading Insanity: Evaluative and Assessment Criteria in Video Biography: Personal Narrative
By Claudia Auger and Ashley Evans

In our study, we will create a rubric specific to the video biography assignment. We will select a variety of evaluators to examine the rubric and grade the sample assignment. The discrepancies and similarities in the assessments of the surveyed individuals will be recorded and analyzed. Our goal is to illuminate points of convolution in evaluative rubrics of video essays.


In the process of collecting data, we will film first impression reactions of the student’s project, ask participants the focus of their evaluation, and collect the graded rubric to calculate the final grade.


In presenting our results, we will incorporate the work of the following scholars: Ede, Lundsford, C. Selfe, Fleischer, Wright, Borton, Huot, D. Selfe, Kitalong, Moore, Takayoshi .


Our final product will appear on a Weebly website that will include video footage, PDF files of the rubric template and graded rubrics, a scholarly analysis, a literature review, and a concluding assessment with findings and acknowledgement of limitations.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

"More Than Words Can Say" Conference Proposal


Hello, Conference Audience: Designating an Audience in Multimodal Assignments 

In their chapter of Multimodal Composition (ed. Cynthia Selfe) entitled “Responding and Assessing,” Sonya C. Borton and Brian Huot discuss the importance of the student’s awareness of their audience in the creation of a multimodal assignment. Just as important, Borton and Huot discuss the essentialness of utilizing the concept of “audience” as the driving force for instructor assessment and evaluation of multimodal assignments. Accompanying this, in “Among the Audience: On Audience in an Age of New Literacies,” Andrea A. Lunsford and Lisa Ede expand upon the creator’s perception of their audience, readers, or “public.”


My presentation examines potential avenues for expanding student perception of audience from beyond the concept of the singular instructor-multimodal evaluator. I will explore the avenues in assignment creation that promote audience-consciousness through the assignment of a production for a particular audience type, level, and mode. This presentation will also discuss the inhibitions and fears in regard to the openness and conceptions of a non-instructor and non-peer audience. Additionally, I will ask the questions, what are the benefits of changing the students’ perception of audience as translated to courses outside of composition? How does the instructor shape students’ perceptions of their audience in publicly available blogs and Wikis? What are the positives and negatives of receiving public response? This presentation will take the form of a dialogue between student and instructor exhibiting the hopes, fears, and anticipations that come with an audience outside of the instructor. 

Thursday, February 17, 2011

Friday, February 11, 2011

Blog Reflection

At the beginning of my blogging experience in English 792, I was terrified of the openness of the topics and the lack of voiced expectation or prompts. Glancing over Ashley’s blog post, I see that she mentioned Xanga as her blogging medium of her past; mine was livejournal. At the time (2003, yeah!) I fancied myself a commentating master. I commented about the MTV show The Real World and also, my own FASCINATING high school career. Speaking of that, I just looked at my old livejournal and saw I took a quiz called “What Middle Earth Flower are you?” I apologize for not linking this gem of my past on here—I hope this is met with understanding. I'm a Niphredel, by the way.

 

Moving on: In 2009, I took a creative non-fiction class that utilized multimodal pedagogy (although I was unaware of it at the time). We were in a computer classroom, and would have online readings as homework. As soon as we entered the class we would blog our reactions to the writing; this included alphabetic text, drawing pictures on Microsoft Paint, linking to online pictures, and even adding audio to the post. Even though I had all these great outlets of expression, I don’t think I ever found myself engaging critically with the reading as I did in English 792 because I generally focused upon the broad meaning(s) of the texts.

Herein lies the problem I first had with my blog posts in English 792—how could I approach ALL the readings in each blog post effectively? How could I cover everything? And also, how formal does this have to be? I’m still not sure about any of this; however, I am sure that the ways I engaged most with our readings was focusing on those aspects that provoked the most thought and contemplation. I am also sure that my growing lack of formality in the blog actually aided me in thinking beyond just surface level analysis of the assigned texts.

Being allowed the freedom to question, praise, and even scoff at some of the readings while simultaneously having the awareness that your blog is read by an audience of peers is a rare privilege. I censored myself, I strived to make my thoughts clearer and more accessible. I was concerned that I would come across as ignorant and adjusted my language and thoughts to (I hope) prevent misconceptions.

I also became uncharacteristically negative. I started picking apart readings and focusing only on aspects that I disliked. The fourth blog post was the height of my negativity and unfair criticism; and although I stand by many of my thoughts in that post, I could definitely have worded this post in a more RESPECTFUL and—dare I say—amiable way.

After a few comments from my peers regarding my tirade, I began to focus on the positives in my reading. I looked at the things I enjoyed—things I would want to employ in my own classroom. Dickie Selfe completely changed my mind using the idea of sustainability to fuel the lives and successes of multimodal classrooms. The readings in Multimodal Composition made me hate even more that our budget is being cut.

Blog comments also kept me in check. I am very grateful to those who read my blog posts and politely informed me of oversights, informed me of concepts I was ignorant of, and proposed new ideas. Similarly, I am glad that I was encouraged to read and comment upon the blogs of others, giving me new perspectives and even blog writing styles.

I suppose it is a rarity to have a blogging community meet twice a week for face-to-face time, but it undoubtedly enriched my blogging experience. Being complimented (and criticized) about my blog in conversation encouraged me to try harder and engage more in the text. Mentioning the blog posts of others to their authors made me feel like a scholar (even though I am a lowly master’s student).

I never though accountability could create such an enriching and enjoyable writing experience—but here it is.


Monday, February 7, 2011

Things aren't always going so wrong.

For this week, I focused on Sylvia Church and Elizabeth Powell’s chapter, “When Things Go Wrong,” sealed the deal on the positives of possibly using a multimodal approach in the non-English 151 classroom.

“Nobody likes to experience failure. It’s painful, frustrating, and humbling. However, in tandem with success, failure can be a powerful teacher” (133). Here, I believe the term “failure,” is too strong, but I wholeheartedly agree with the main idea; when one is forced to make changes, do things over, and go back and examine an unsuccessful work or attempt, it becomes more of a learning experience than simple success. One day, I hope that multimodal classrooms become the norm (or at least quite a bit more common), but for now I think that these classrooms will be overwhelmingly marked with the struggles and issues marked with experimental, and yes, learning through ‘unsuccesses.’

My concerns: Church and Powell stress that students in these burgeoning multimodal environments should have plenty of time and also work through collaboration to create their multimodal assignments. Instructors should recognize that they might not have communicated their requirements (assignment-wise or technology-wise) effectively. Talking about time is cliché; I know, I apologize. But the idea of giving students enough time to do and redo their assignments unsettles me. I realize that the majority of us are slaves to technology and mistakes can happen, but what about those students that procrastinate? And what about those who lose their assignment once and become discouraged…too discouraged to continue?

And what about those students who are forced to focus primarily on acquiring technological skills and not the expressive/learning skills that the assignment hopes to reinforce or introduce the student to? And if that’s the case, what is the overall point of the assignment: adeptness with the medium or fulfilling the non-technological aspect of the prompt? And and and…or or or?




As I type this, I know that attitudes will change. If multimodal classrooms become the norm, troubleshooting will be easier. Compulsive saving will be more compulsive and file formats will have better conversions. Students will enter the class (hopefully?) having a knowledge base to pull from to learn new skills; and teachers will already be the skills experts. Right?

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Clinkers and Gems! But mostly gems...

Although I’ve continued my skepticism in regard to the practicality of using new media in the classroom, Dr. Dickie Selfe’s “Techno-Pedagogical Explorations: Toward Sustatinable Technology-Rich Instruction” comments on local sustainable teaching practices has changed my opinion. I am glad that I read the short article before reading Multimodal Composition; because the use of technology and computers in the classroom is a great idea—if you have the interest and funding.

“In order to sustain your own interest and commitment, imagine practical pedagogical objectives that you believe a communication technology (or technologies) might help you accomplish, one that would be difficult to accomplish in your traditional class (however you define traditional).” (20)

How great! And as a side note, how refreshing is this writing style? Imagine a whole classroom focused primarily upon pedagogy with communication technologies sprinkled in not only to introduce the class to different ways of communication, but also technologies that they may use in their future careers. Also, imagine a pedagogical approach that admits outright that it is not perfect; it admits that there is always room for improvement.

“Let the students in on your objectives, and explain them over and over during the term. This is experimental work; students aren’t used to teachings being so forthright with them…” (20)

Instructor honesty is the most undervalued quality in pedagogy. Tell the students why you’re assigning them the paper, the grammar worksheet, and the group work they think is busywork. When they get frustrated with the technology and ask: “why are we even doing this?” they will already know the answer to the question. The class will be something they signed up for. They were told classroom objectives and concerns on the first day.

Not only that, they find that their work will be showcased and valued by someone other than the instructor. I know all the essays that are written in my class are written FOR me. My students are aware that I am the only individual who passes judgment on their contributions in class, and this is reflected in their work accordingly. This may have a positive or negative influence on their submissions, as they believe the essay may only be read once and thrown away, or maybe kept on as an example essay. With the introduction of technology in the classroom a wider audience can be reached. People all across the world can read, view, and pass judgment on the students’ works. This is something we discussed the first day of class regarding blogging. Students are more likely to spend time on something that is viewed by their peers. Their peers have been afforded the same opportunities in class and therefore can compare the viewed work to their own. Is it with a critical and unfair eye? I have no idea. But that’s what the working world is about, and that is what we should be preparing our students for.

However, one of Dr. Selfe’s comments that I would like to have clarified is his suggestion to use extra-credit as a motivator to try different media and comment on the work of others. I struggle with this concept because it seems to isolate those who do not have an interest in the particular subject of the time. How is it fair that the third group can go back and comment on the first group’s work, but the first does not have the opportunity? Dr. Selfe also mentions student leaders grading student work. How are these leaders selected? Are they given grading training? Or are they not even members of the class?

I’m just picking at things now, but in regards to a locally sustainable teaching practice and local collaboration: “:-)” (22).

------------------------------------------------------------------------

And now some quick questions about Dr. Cynthia Selfe’s edited Multimodal Composition chapters.

Page 43 suggests relay work: “Reduce frustration by limiting the length of any one student’s work session. Suggest that students who become frustrated by the technology hand off work on the project to another group member.” Does this sound like passing the buck? I recalled when Jon H. spoke of assuming group work responsibilities in his undergraduate career. Is this the same thing? Or is it a more collaborative environment?

“Emotional rewards,” mentioned on page 39 are frequently alluded to in these chapters. What is the extent of these rewards? Should we be taking “emotional rewards” into consideration in our own teaching methods? I may be wrestling with phraseology over meaning here.

Page 36 discusses the advantages of inviting “knowledgeable consultants” to work with students for a class period. I wholeheartedly agree with this, but struggle to imagine an environment at OU that would allow this. Is anyone aware of computer composition courses here that utilize or could utilize this practice?