For this week, I focused on Sylvia Church and Elizabeth Powell’s chapter, “When Things Go Wrong,” sealed the deal on the positives of possibly using a multimodal approach in the non-English 151 classroom.
“Nobody likes to experience failure. It’s painful, frustrating, and humbling. However, in tandem with success, failure can be a powerful teacher” (133). Here, I believe the term “failure,” is too strong, but I wholeheartedly agree with the main idea; when one is forced to make changes, do things over, and go back and examine an unsuccessful work or attempt, it becomes more of a learning experience than simple success. One day, I hope that multimodal classrooms become the norm (or at least quite a bit more common), but for now I think that these classrooms will be overwhelmingly marked with the struggles and issues marked with experimental, and yes, learning through ‘unsuccesses.’
My concerns: Church and Powell stress that students in these burgeoning multimodal environments should have plenty of time and also work through collaboration to create their multimodal assignments. Instructors should recognize that they might not have communicated their requirements (assignment-wise or technology-wise) effectively. Talking about time is cliché; I know, I apologize. But the idea of giving students enough time to do and redo their assignments unsettles me. I realize that the majority of us are slaves to technology and mistakes can happen, but what about those students that procrastinate? And what about those who lose their assignment once and become discouraged…too discouraged to continue?
And what about those students who are forced to focus primarily on acquiring technological skills and not the expressive/learning skills that the assignment hopes to reinforce or introduce the student to? And if that’s the case, what is the overall point of the assignment: adeptness with the medium or fulfilling the non-technological aspect of the prompt? And and and…or or or?
As I type this, I know that attitudes will change. If multimodal classrooms become the norm, troubleshooting will be easier. Compulsive saving will be more compulsive and file formats will have better conversions. Students will enter the class (hopefully?) having a knowledge base to pull from to learn new skills; and teachers will already be the skills experts. Right?
3 comments:
Claudia--
You say, "One day, I hope that multimodal classrooms become the norm..."
Do you really mean this? Perhaps I should first ask what a "multimodal classroom" means. Integrating technology? The end of alphabetic text? No more paragraph essays? And are you talking about 151 or other English classes?
Other than my attack of questions, I'm with you on the time thing. (My notes in the margins scream, "TIME IS FLEETING!") If a student loses his or her project, should we give an extension? If a student claims he or she lost his or her entire essay, do we give them extensions?
Everything changes. (Cue foreboding music.)
To the time issue, I would add the effect of access on time. If students only have access to the technology necessary to complete the assignment when they are in class, how many class periods do we devote to just letting them work?
With an academically rigorous assignment, I would think you'd have to spend at least an entire week or more just letting the student complete the assignment with the technology in class. Ouch!
John has a good point about the time issue that I did not think about much before. I also was concerned about the time. It really might be necessary to take a week of class time to let students use the technology available in class to work on their projects. At first I wondered if I would really want to take that much class tiime for that, but then, don't some of us already take some class time to bring students to a computer lab to work on research or their papers during class time? Many of us set aside class periods for individual conferences. If we set aside time in class for students to write and revise, then why not set aside time for students to use the available technology?
Of course, much of this might depend on what is available to students outside the classroom. If there are other technology labs available outside of class time and technology available for students to "check out" outside of class time, this might not be a big issue.
Post a Comment