Monday, January 10, 2011

Perceptions of "New Media" (make me want to get a tattoo that tells a story)


THE PROMPT: to comment on Anne Frances Wysocki’s approach to defining “new media” in the Introduction of Writing New Media: Theory and Applications for Expanding the Teaching of Composition. In my reading, I focused in particular on how Wysocki discusses different forms of “new media” that disseminate/stifle/accept information and my own encounters with these forms.

On page 7, Wysocki discusses how online forums and message boards can allow a more creative form of expression with face or name anonymity, but also just as easily silence people from expressing their own opinions. In this respect, Wysocki uses the example of a Latino and Anglo classroom. Although I believe this example is a valid one, it does not directly address the overwhelming freedom and abuse offered by and taking place on these “new media” message boards.

I was reminded of the case of an eleven-year-old girl on the forums of 4Chan. Under her screen name, the young girl posted inflammatory videos insulting other 4Chan users. This caused a backlash against her online that developed into off-forum harassment beginning when her full name, address, and phone number were posted online. People visited her house leaving harassing objects or messages, and even left death threats on her family’s voicemail.

In the case of 4Chan and the Anglo/Latino classroom, “new media” is used as a tool of harassment. But what if it was more heavily regulated? What if anonymity was removed? I doubt that the Anglo individuals would have insulted those of Latino heritage in a face-to-face interaction, just as I doubt anyone would threaten an eleven-year-old child. It is the anonymity that breeds animosity and hatred without consequences. “New media” itself is too new to breed respect and civility without rules and regulations. But then, this poses a further problem because the rules and regulations already in place function for older forms of media and communication, i.e. black text on white paper. Can these traditional rules be co-opted for “new media”?

It at the mention of this standard (the 8 ½” by 11 white paper), that Wysocki outlines our perception of “new media” as scholars. Do we take Internet forums seriously? Probably not, but people rely on blogs more and more for up to date information and well-articulated opinions. On page 12, Wysocki poses: “Imagine, for example, that this book now before you were bound in leather or in large fishlike scales.… Imagine this chapter were appearing paragraph by paragraph in an Instant Messager window” (Wysocki  12). The reader’s attitude will reflect the perceived attitude of the text. Visual layouts mark the reader’s experience with the text; and it is truly the reader’s experience, not the reading alone that creates the overall impression of the media.

 

5 comments:

Amanda said...

That's a good example of the potential drawbacks of internet anonymity, both in and outside of the classroom. It recalls for me the time-line we looked at the first day of class, in which the utopian hopes of online interactions destroying sexism and racism were themselves smashed by the racist/sexist reality of those same anonymous interactions. I didn't think Wysocki gave much focus to issues of classroom regulation concerning things like blogs and message boards, but I would like to know her thoughts. Whose job is it to regulate? What should the regulations be? In the age when "cyberbullying" has become a common term and people are killing themselves over net-based harrassment, I don't think the question of regulation is going to go away any time soon.

Lana O. said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lana O. said...

I share with you and Amanda the same concern over the freedom and the abuse offered by new media and the freedom to abuse new media. While access is something that we all want, it's not something that everyone may be able to control. Also, although technology, especially the Internet is controlled by corporations striving mainly for profit, many believe that it is a tool of democracy that will liberate and equalize users/consumers/students.

John Faustus said...

Your focus on the ethics of new media and the responsibilities of its composers raises some interesting and complicated issues. I think that the notion of regulating the internet worries many people, as we have seen in the recent controversy over FCC discussions of net neutrality. At the same time, how can we expect people to act responsibly in an environment with no consequences for irresponsibility? That's why I think that your suggestion about losing anonymity is an intriguing one. But at what point would that inhibit free speech?

Bryan A. Lutz said...

As some of you know, I waste a lot of my time debating politics on facebook. It is such a difficult enterprise and for the reasons Claudia is drawing attention to. People are willing to challenge me on issues of gender, sexuality and race in a way that they certainly would not have had they been looking me in the face. Particularly people are able to challenge my sexuality in a way that is hurtful, degrading and worse. Something about third space facilitates disembodiment, allowing hate to flow freely. I can say know this well.

To John's point of censorship, it does allow people to express precisely how they feel and maybe that needs to happen so we can address the ideas. The problem is positioning someone to defend their right to be. Hate speech. The problem with hate speech is there is no disembodiment from the person the speech is directed toward in the real world. The consequence is only felt by the victim in Third space, the perpetrator is protected by their anonymity.

One final point, net-neutrality does raise this issue in an indirect way. If the internet becomes stratified, and service providers can pick and choose content, then now a corporate entity can control the flow of information. If knowledge is power, than they now have control of nearly all of it.