This week, I decided to give online essays more of a chance. Like many in the class, I struggle with staring at the screen, not being able to take notes unless I bring up a Word Document side by side on a monitor larger than two large pizzas. With that in mind, I’m going to get all the normal complaints out of the way.
Collin Brooke’s “Remediation”
Form
- Only forward navigation
- No printable read out (a move with purpose, I think)
- No end in sight, I was not able to return to the same spot on a different computer
Now that that’s over with--does anyone else struggle with the constant reappropriation of the meaning of terms? The dictionary definition of remediation is: “the correction of something bad or defective.” However, according to Bolter and Grusin on Brooke’s site, remediation is “the representation of one medium in another.” The definition of “medium” is also manipulated to serve the purpose of the reappropriated definition of remediation: “that which appropriates the techniques, forms, and social significance of the other media and attempts to rival or refashion them into the name of the real.”
What I would have appreciated here is a definition of what Collins/Bolter/Grusin believe to be “the real.” Instead, the reader/viewer is offered a trite statement regarding the ever-changing technologies of the world. Are all “mediums” flawed at the core? Can they ever achieve “the real?” Is “the real” the interaction between media? If that’s the case, the website would have benefited exponentially from the removal of the global (memetic) vs. local issues paragraph. Local issues can only be ignored to a point; for example, my English 151 students just submitted their Summary/Strong Response papers. In my first read-through of these papers I focused entirely on global issues: “are the ideas original?” is the prompt being followed adequately?” In the second read I look for local issues that include grammar, spelling, transitions, etc. They are graded on both global and local issues. Local issues can destroy the global impact. No matter how excellent the ideas are, too many local mistakes can undermine an entire meaning. The same is true within local issues and memetic issues in new media.
Let me try again. This website, as a medium and an embodiment of remediation, is “memetically” sound as it has a global argument of change in both academics and technology; however, it is undermined by the local issues of navigation, superfluous flash animation, and form clipart.
Similarly, the statement “both physically and figuratively, to read a text is to place one’s self above it, to position one’s self outside of it,” is wrought with the contradiction of its own medium. When I am staring at the computer screen, I am face to face with the text. I am engaging in a conversation with the author—or the medium—of the remediation. With every click, I am interacting, and waiting to be led, I am not “above the text” in this sense. Is this what Brooke means when he says: “all lookers are not created equal?” Am I placing myself above the text?
Finally, I’m still at a loss as to how the “perspective” of electronic writing has restored anything that humanity has lost over time. What sort of oratory skills have been restored by new media, or by this website?
2 comments:
I am also distracted by the design of some of these new media academic texts to the point where I have to take a second look, go back, and read aloud to get it. One problem might be that this kind of new media text is too new. The rhetorical effectiveness of such texts still needs to be explored further. It seems as though some of these authors are attempting new media without thinking through the reasons behind their design choices, other than the idea that if they have a design option, they should use it.
Hitching onto Matthew's comment and your note of the website's "superfluous flash animation," I would like to bring up the question of learning. Whenever I read these online interactive things I do not process them as well as when I have paper in front of me. Perhaps it is because note-taking isn't easy--and is very removed from the reading--or because I cannot learn visually. I remember visually, but cannot learn visually. Weird, no?
My point is that some people might get a lot out of a new media lesson and others might just be blinded by the lights.
Post a Comment