Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Clinkers and Gems! But mostly gems...

Although I’ve continued my skepticism in regard to the practicality of using new media in the classroom, Dr. Dickie Selfe’s “Techno-Pedagogical Explorations: Toward Sustatinable Technology-Rich Instruction” comments on local sustainable teaching practices has changed my opinion. I am glad that I read the short article before reading Multimodal Composition; because the use of technology and computers in the classroom is a great idea—if you have the interest and funding.

“In order to sustain your own interest and commitment, imagine practical pedagogical objectives that you believe a communication technology (or technologies) might help you accomplish, one that would be difficult to accomplish in your traditional class (however you define traditional).” (20)

How great! And as a side note, how refreshing is this writing style? Imagine a whole classroom focused primarily upon pedagogy with communication technologies sprinkled in not only to introduce the class to different ways of communication, but also technologies that they may use in their future careers. Also, imagine a pedagogical approach that admits outright that it is not perfect; it admits that there is always room for improvement.

“Let the students in on your objectives, and explain them over and over during the term. This is experimental work; students aren’t used to teachings being so forthright with them…” (20)

Instructor honesty is the most undervalued quality in pedagogy. Tell the students why you’re assigning them the paper, the grammar worksheet, and the group work they think is busywork. When they get frustrated with the technology and ask: “why are we even doing this?” they will already know the answer to the question. The class will be something they signed up for. They were told classroom objectives and concerns on the first day.

Not only that, they find that their work will be showcased and valued by someone other than the instructor. I know all the essays that are written in my class are written FOR me. My students are aware that I am the only individual who passes judgment on their contributions in class, and this is reflected in their work accordingly. This may have a positive or negative influence on their submissions, as they believe the essay may only be read once and thrown away, or maybe kept on as an example essay. With the introduction of technology in the classroom a wider audience can be reached. People all across the world can read, view, and pass judgment on the students’ works. This is something we discussed the first day of class regarding blogging. Students are more likely to spend time on something that is viewed by their peers. Their peers have been afforded the same opportunities in class and therefore can compare the viewed work to their own. Is it with a critical and unfair eye? I have no idea. But that’s what the working world is about, and that is what we should be preparing our students for.

However, one of Dr. Selfe’s comments that I would like to have clarified is his suggestion to use extra-credit as a motivator to try different media and comment on the work of others. I struggle with this concept because it seems to isolate those who do not have an interest in the particular subject of the time. How is it fair that the third group can go back and comment on the first group’s work, but the first does not have the opportunity? Dr. Selfe also mentions student leaders grading student work. How are these leaders selected? Are they given grading training? Or are they not even members of the class?

I’m just picking at things now, but in regards to a locally sustainable teaching practice and local collaboration: “:-)” (22).

------------------------------------------------------------------------

And now some quick questions about Dr. Cynthia Selfe’s edited Multimodal Composition chapters.

Page 43 suggests relay work: “Reduce frustration by limiting the length of any one student’s work session. Suggest that students who become frustrated by the technology hand off work on the project to another group member.” Does this sound like passing the buck? I recalled when Jon H. spoke of assuming group work responsibilities in his undergraduate career. Is this the same thing? Or is it a more collaborative environment?

“Emotional rewards,” mentioned on page 39 are frequently alluded to in these chapters. What is the extent of these rewards? Should we be taking “emotional rewards” into consideration in our own teaching methods? I may be wrestling with phraseology over meaning here.

Page 36 discusses the advantages of inviting “knowledgeable consultants” to work with students for a class period. I wholeheartedly agree with this, but struggle to imagine an environment at OU that would allow this. Is anyone aware of computer composition courses here that utilize or could utilize this practice?

5 comments:

Amanda said...

In addition to the other refreshing aspects (such as his writing style and his experimental, honesty-driven take on classroom media) of Dickie Selfe's article, I loved his use of the emoticon! (On page 22...) I'm an emoticon junkie; sometimes a written expression, particularly in an email, just comes off as more serious or grim than I intended. The emoticon is a great communicator in that respect. Though I'm not quite ready to have my students use emoticons in their papers...

John Faustus said...

Claudia, I think that your responses and questions are both valid and interesting. A word of caution though about the audience stuff: Dickie Selfe talks about the need to help construct that external audience, that instructors cannot just have students posting things to the internet and expect them to be read/viewed/experienced by anyone outside of the classroom. I would go a step further and add that even if students know that their work will reach an audience beyond the instructor, they won't be fully aware of that audience until after they have received some kind of feedback from them. So the external audience ought to be brought into the composing process somehow.

Also, I think that there is a difference between delegating or shuffling responsibilities and passing the buck. The key is accountability. With collaborative projects, I like to receive individual progress reports (though not every day, as Cynthia Self suggests), but I also find it useful to inform students at the outset that they will be evaluating each other at the end of the project. After the project is completed, I ask students to fill out an evaluation sheet, part of which asks them to come up with an individual grade for each group member (including a self grade). This has helped me a lot while grading collaborative projects.

Lastly, regarding "knowledgable consultants," I wonder if contacting former students and/or fellow TAs might be a good method for recruiting such people. In undergrad, I took a class in literary publishing, in which I helped edit and produce the school's literary journal. The following year, when the professor was teaching the same class, she contacted me and asked for help teaching the new students how to create the electronic version of the journal. I was happy to help, and it was a very enjoyable experience, but I also now realize how clever it was on her part to solicit former students for volunteer work.

Matthew said...

I agree with you about the extra credit thing. I think instructors who are interested in building a "technology-rich" curriculum, as Selfe calls it, need to be very careful about their interactions with and treatments of students who are not completely comfortable or assimilated into digital culture. This includes older students, returning to college, as well as those who come from economic backgrounds which didn't allow as much high technology in the home.

Bryan A. Lutz said...

"Let the students in on your objectives, and explain them over and over during the term. This is experimental work; students aren’t used to teachings being so forthright with them…" (20)

I liked that quote too, and it has Flower and Hayes written all over it. It's the cognitivists approach of having a goal-oriented process with the specific expectations clearly outlined. You make a great point that it takes away the 'busywork' feel of the assignments. Instead it is a means to an ever-evolving end.

Ash Evans said...

Claudia--

I haven't heard this kind of excitement from you since you heard it was reggae night at Casa!!