Sunday, January 23, 2011

What is "real" anyway?


This week, I decided to give online essays more of a chance. Like many in the class, I struggle with staring at the screen, not being able to take notes unless I bring up a Word Document side by side on a monitor larger than two large pizzas. With that in mind, I’m going to get all the normal complaints out of the way.

Collin Brooke’s “Remediation”
Form
    1. Only forward navigation
    2. No printable read out (a move with purpose, I think)
    3. No end in sight, I was not able to return to the same spot on a different computer

Now that that’s over with--does anyone else struggle with the constant reappropriation of the meaning of terms? The dictionary definition of remediation is: “the correction of something bad or defective.” However, according to Bolter and Grusin on Brooke’s site, remediation is “the representation of one medium in another.” The definition of “medium” is also manipulated to serve the purpose of the reappropriated definition of remediation: “that which appropriates the techniques, forms, and social significance of the other media and attempts to rival or refashion them into the name of the real.”

What I would have appreciated here is a definition of what Collins/Bolter/Grusin believe to be “the real.” Instead, the reader/viewer is offered a trite statement regarding the ever-changing technologies of the world. Are all “mediums” flawed at the core? Can they ever achieve “the real?” Is “the real” the interaction between media? If that’s the case, the website would have benefited exponentially from the removal of the global (memetic) vs. local issues paragraph. Local issues can only be ignored to a point; for example, my English 151 students just submitted their Summary/Strong Response papers. In my first read-through of these papers I focused entirely on global issues: “are the ideas original?” is the prompt being followed adequately?” In the second read I look for local issues that include grammar, spelling, transitions, etc. They are graded on both global and local issues. Local issues can destroy the global impact. No matter how excellent the ideas are, too many local mistakes can undermine an entire meaning.  The same is true within local issues and memetic issues in new media.

Let me try again. This website, as a medium and an embodiment of remediation, is “memetically” sound as it has a global argument of change in both academics and technology; however, it is undermined by the local issues of navigation, superfluous flash animation, and form clipart.

Similarly, the statement “both physically and figuratively, to read a text is to place one’s self above it, to position one’s self outside of it,” is wrought with the contradiction of its own medium. When I am staring at the computer screen, I am face to face with the text. I am engaging in a conversation with the author—or the medium—of the remediation. With every click, I am interacting, and waiting to be led, I am not “above the text” in this sense.  Is this what Brooke means when he says: “all lookers are not created equal?” Am I placing myself above the text?

Finally, I’m still at a loss as to how the “perspective” of electronic writing has restored anything that humanity has lost over time. What sort of oratory skills have been restored by new media, or by this website?

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Boosting authority...of what?


As I spent a 72 hour period lying on my couch this weekend (thanking whichever greater power you choose that I was not yet missing class), I thought about how great it would be if one did miss class that there was a remote, computer option, in which one could interact with the class before/during/after it took place. But then I realized that this is in part, what our blogs are for. In J. Elizabeth Clark’s “The Digital Imperative: Making the Case for a 21st Century Pedagogy.” The blogs relate both the class theme and the tastes of the reader, offering up new and unique views on course material, sometimes even bringing in material from outside. After reading each student’s course blog, one would have multiple views on different assigned articles, presenting a rough classroom experience (of course nothing can compare to guided class discussion).

Commenting on the blogs adds an interactive element to the classroom where one is not permitted to merely skim another student’s work. This work may be even more well-thought than an ordinary homework assignment turned into the instructor because it is placed in a public forum where the whole classroom can see. These comments and posts can also become a teachable moment in source evaluation, or as Clark says to “cite that information as authoritative, and thus gain facility in differentiating between reliable and unreliable sources” (Clark 34).

This is where my agreement with Clark ends in the section pertaining blogs. The author goes on to describe the “crafting [of] a digital identity” (Clark 34). Allowing students to claim authority on the subjects they write about does not make a realistic bridge to their future classes. Don’t get me wrong, I grant them, and myself, as much authority as is due, but what Clark is asking is the equivalent of having someone write at the end of a lab report: “I think that this is interesting because…” Clark states that she has the concept of audience and improved rhetorical moves in mind for improvement of students’ skills; however, having a student embrace the idea that they are THE authoritative source on an argument is not the way to improve their own skills of debate and compromise. There is a difference between “tak[ing] ownership over their argument…[and] research” and fielding an argument and research (Clark 34).

I think, like Ashley states in her blog, that I might be a Luddite. At first I was very enthusiastic about the idea of online expression through new media (particularly blogs). However, as I teach my engineering, nursing, and biology students in English 151, I don’t want to give them the wrong (and I think dangerous) idea about authority, knowledge, research, and the hierarchy of their own future professions.

Monday, January 10, 2011

Perceptions of "New Media" (make me want to get a tattoo that tells a story)


THE PROMPT: to comment on Anne Frances Wysocki’s approach to defining “new media” in the Introduction of Writing New Media: Theory and Applications for Expanding the Teaching of Composition. In my reading, I focused in particular on how Wysocki discusses different forms of “new media” that disseminate/stifle/accept information and my own encounters with these forms.

On page 7, Wysocki discusses how online forums and message boards can allow a more creative form of expression with face or name anonymity, but also just as easily silence people from expressing their own opinions. In this respect, Wysocki uses the example of a Latino and Anglo classroom. Although I believe this example is a valid one, it does not directly address the overwhelming freedom and abuse offered by and taking place on these “new media” message boards.

I was reminded of the case of an eleven-year-old girl on the forums of 4Chan. Under her screen name, the young girl posted inflammatory videos insulting other 4Chan users. This caused a backlash against her online that developed into off-forum harassment beginning when her full name, address, and phone number were posted online. People visited her house leaving harassing objects or messages, and even left death threats on her family’s voicemail.

In the case of 4Chan and the Anglo/Latino classroom, “new media” is used as a tool of harassment. But what if it was more heavily regulated? What if anonymity was removed? I doubt that the Anglo individuals would have insulted those of Latino heritage in a face-to-face interaction, just as I doubt anyone would threaten an eleven-year-old child. It is the anonymity that breeds animosity and hatred without consequences. “New media” itself is too new to breed respect and civility without rules and regulations. But then, this poses a further problem because the rules and regulations already in place function for older forms of media and communication, i.e. black text on white paper. Can these traditional rules be co-opted for “new media”?

It at the mention of this standard (the 8 ½” by 11 white paper), that Wysocki outlines our perception of “new media” as scholars. Do we take Internet forums seriously? Probably not, but people rely on blogs more and more for up to date information and well-articulated opinions. On page 12, Wysocki poses: “Imagine, for example, that this book now before you were bound in leather or in large fishlike scales.… Imagine this chapter were appearing paragraph by paragraph in an Instant Messager window” (Wysocki  12). The reader’s attitude will reflect the perceived attitude of the text. Visual layouts mark the reader’s experience with the text; and it is truly the reader’s experience, not the reading alone that creates the overall impression of the media.

 

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Introductory Post

Hello, my name is Claudia Auger. I'm from a small town near Cincinnati called Loveland. At the moment, I live in Athens with my dog and four birds. In 2008 I created this blog URL using two of my birds' names: Blueberry and Banana.