As I spent a 72 hour period lying on my couch this weekend (thanking whichever greater power you choose that I was not yet missing class), I thought about how great it would be if one did miss class that there was a remote, computer option, in which one could interact with the class before/during/after it took place. But then I realized that this is in part, what our blogs are for. In J. Elizabeth Clark’s “The Digital Imperative: Making the Case for a 21st Century Pedagogy.” The blogs relate both the class theme and the tastes of the reader, offering up new and unique views on course material, sometimes even bringing in material from outside. After reading each student’s course blog, one would have multiple views on different assigned articles, presenting a rough classroom experience (of course nothing can compare to guided class discussion).
Commenting on the blogs adds an interactive element to the classroom where one is not permitted to merely skim another student’s work. This work may be even more well-thought than an ordinary homework assignment turned into the instructor because it is placed in a public forum where the whole classroom can see. These comments and posts can also become a teachable moment in source evaluation, or as Clark says to “cite that information as authoritative, and thus gain facility in differentiating between reliable and unreliable sources” (Clark 34).
This is where my agreement with Clark ends in the section pertaining blogs. The author goes on to describe the “crafting [of] a digital identity” (Clark 34). Allowing students to claim authority on the subjects they write about does not make a realistic bridge to their future classes. Don’t get me wrong, I grant them, and myself, as much authority as is due, but what Clark is asking is the equivalent of having someone write at the end of a lab report: “I think that this is interesting because…” Clark states that she has the concept of audience and improved rhetorical moves in mind for improvement of students’ skills; however, having a student embrace the idea that they are THE authoritative source on an argument is not the way to improve their own skills of debate and compromise. There is a difference between “tak[ing] ownership over their argument…[and] research” and fielding an argument and research (Clark 34).
I think, like Ashley states in her blog, that I might be a Luddite. At first I was very enthusiastic about the idea of online expression through new media (particularly blogs). However, as I teach my engineering, nursing, and biology students in English 151, I don’t want to give them the wrong (and I think dangerous) idea about authority, knowledge, research, and the hierarchy of their own future professions.
3 comments:
That's an interesting and relevant point, not only to the teaching of new media (though it certainly applies there) but to all communication. How do we encourage students to feel authority and ownership of their texts (hoping that this will give them a greater stake in the production of these texts) without feeding a perhaps national narcissism that tells students they are always the most important/authoritative voice there is? By the by, for one prof's take on the idea of student narcissism, read the article "Hell's Classroom" from the Chronicle of Higher Education (http://chronicle.com/article/Hells-Classroom/44811/).
"I thought about how great it would be if one did miss class that there was a remote, computer option, in which one could interact with the class before/during/after it took place."
As I was bedridden Tuesday, I pondered this too, and even considered Skyping to (into?) class.
You know those commercials with Ellen Page for Cisco where the kids are screeching at their Chinese friends? Well, Cisco claims to be "the worldwide leader in networking that transforms how people connect, communicate and collaborate." And in this commercial, they say it is "the new classroom."
Apparently there is a conversation outside of our class readings. Apparently, the world is changing at a national level, which means it is only time before our classrooms will be changing as well.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHFUwFgu5w4
I think that giving students a sense of themselves as an authority can be an important part of composition pedagogy, especially because I feel that it's one of the things I still struggle with a lot in my own compositions. I've also seen a number of student essays that tried to use sources to make an argument because the student didn't believe he/she had the authority to make his/her own argument. New media can be a helpful means of accomplishing this because it allows them to publish their work; however, as I've mentioned in my own blog post, we shouldn't assume that they'll recognize the public audience for whom they are writing. I think that makes it more complicated. Also, as you point out, maybe establishing a sense of authority isn't or shouldn't be the highest priority in the classroom.
Post a Comment